Miami Bus Ads Ask Ex-Muslims: “Fatwa on Your Head?”

“Is your family or your community threatening you?”

Robert Spencer and Pamela Geller have come up with a new wheeze: anti-Muslim bus ads on the sides of buses in Miami. Here’s the poster:

Geller tells us that:

Our pro-freedom campaign rolled out today on the following buses all over Miami — Route 3 (Biscayne Blvd and US1), Route 88 (Kendall Drive SW 88th Street, from the Dade and North Metro Rail station to SW 80th street), Route 40 (Bird Road SW 40th Street), Route L (Hialeah along 79th Street Causeway, Collins Avenue to Miami Beach Convention Center), Route E (Collins Avenue), Route 11 (FIU Bus terminal to FIU South campus, West Flagler street ends at Government center Metro station) — split between curb side and street side. 

Spencer explains that:

One of the first projects that we’ve been working on for Stop the Islamization of America and the Freedom Defense Initiative organization that I started with Pamela Geller was this bus ad campaign… This is the first time anyone has offered public help to those who are threatened under Islam’s apostasy law. In the Land of the Free, government and law enforcement should be on this. But they aren’t. So we are. It is time for free citizens to stand for freedom — or lose it.

Spencer and Geller agreed to take charge of Stop Islamization of America a couple of weeks ago, at the request of Anders Gravers and Stephen Gash of Stop Islamisation of Europe; SIOA, as I blogged here, was formed in September (at the time the link to SIOE was not clear; DL Adams and Kendra Adams of the New English Review were named as the SIOA founders [1]). Spencer goes on to pose a rhetorical question:

…Why did we create and organize a bus ad campaign to offer resources to Muslims who want to leave Islam but feel threatened?

Because you realised it’s a clever way to annoy Muslims, since if anyone objects you can accuse them of acquiescing in threats against ex-Muslims? Apparently not…

 We wanted to show that some people will stand up against violent intimidation, some people will stand up for religious freedom in America. And we wanted to counterbalance the smooth deceptions of the CAIR campaign. We wanted to show that some people will stand up against violent intimidation, some people will stand up for religious freedom in America. And we wanted to counterbalance the smooth deceptions of the CAIR campaign.

…Sharia law holds no weight or legitimacy here. Apostates are free to leave Islam and to be who and whatever that want to be.

In January 2009, CAIR had run a number of bus adverts offering Muslim literature; Fort Lauderdale’s Christian fundamentalist mayor Jim Naugle had called for these to banned (a demand Spencer implicitly endorsed).

The “Refuge from Islam” website promises to “call public attention” to cases that they are contacted about. However, the “resources” on offer at the site are a token effort: there is a link to an evangelical Christian apologetics site, and links to Amazon pages for books by Robert Spencer and Ibn Warriq. Three women’s shelters in Miami are listed, since Miami is “site of the first SIOA Religious Freedom Campaign”. That’s about it – but, of course, the ads are primarily a stunt calculated to provoke rather than a serious effort to help closet ex-Muslims extricate themselves from difficult (and of course sometimes dangerous) circumstances.

Spencer also tells us that the design for the bus ad was developed “with the help of the enormously talented Big Fur Hat“. BigFurHat is a conservative satirist who is also responsible for the new SIOA logo; before Christmas, he designed a Christmas card for Geller’s readers to print out and send to Rifqa Bary, the ex-Muslim teenager who claims that her Muslim parents want to kill her and who is currently in foster care and the subject of a court case. That was another stunt: not unexpectly, Bary’s parents objected to their daughter receiving a deluge of letters from strangers that might contain all kinds of ravings, and they asserted through their lawyers that the cards should be intercepted because “the [Guardian ad Litem] for Fathima Rifqa Bary, [Franklin County Children Services] and the parents of the minor child have a right to know when third parties are communicating to the minor child particularly when the third parties might endanger the health and safety of the minor child.” This was inevitably picked up by various sites (including Fox News) as further evidence of Muslim heartlessness (the motion was eventually dropped for unstated reasons). The card also advertised BigFurHat’s satirical website, I Own the World; the site is largely devoted to anti-Obama and anti-liberal jibes, some of which tend towards the coarse.

I blogged on the general trend for using bus ads for religious controversy here.

UPDATE (16 April): It is now being reported that the adverts have been pulled by the bus company; according to the Miami Herald:

…on Thursday, Miami-Dade Transit spokeswoman Karla Damian said that after reviewing the ads, the department decided they “may be offensive to Islam” and would remove them before the buses ran on Friday.

Damian said the ads were able to initially go up because Miami-Dade Transit has an outside company sell ad space and does not routinely review ads before they run.

The South Florida chapter of the Council on American-Islamic Relations had critiqued the ads as promoting “bigotry” and making false statements about Islam.

Spencer has responded to this with the pronouncement that Miami-Dade Transit is “submitting to Sharia and Islamic supremacist intimidation” and with an appeal for funds – inevitably, SIOA intends to sue:

We are deeply grateful that David Yerushalmi, P.C., an expert in Sharia, and The Thomas More Law center are taking this case on a pro bono basis. But there are many costs involved — and so please donate to the legal fund. Any funds we can raise to offset David Yerushalmi’s costs will allow him to take on more cases like these — and nothing is more certain than that there will be more.

I wrote a blog entry on Yerushalmi’s supposed expertise in Shariah here.

UPDATE 2 (21 April): The ads are now back up; SIOA reports that

By Friday, the day after the bus ads had been pulled, Mr. Yerushalmi and his co-counsel Robert Muise were prepared to go into federal court early the next week. A teleconference was arranged first with the Miami-Dade County Attorney’s office, which took place Monday afternoon. After listening to Mr. Yerushalmi’s brief, the county attorneys conceded the ads should not have been pulled. By Tuesday, Mr. Yerushalmi had negotiated a full and complete retraction of the contract termination with a NY-based attorney for CBS Outdoor. Not only would the original 10 king-sized ads go back up on the Transit Authority buses, but CBS would run an additional 20 king-sized bus ads for the same original contract price.

***

[1] Kendra Adams has now posted a statement on the NER Facebook page announcing that “Our affiliation which many here noted and followed with an organization that opposes the growth of Islam in the United States is now at an end. While the affiliation is concluded, the work continues”, oddly failing to mention SIOA by name. The SIOE website, meanwhile, tells us that “Pamela Geller and Robert Spencer are deeply grateful to Kendra Adams for her previous work with SIOA, and applaud her dedication to the cause of stopping the spread of Sharia in the United States.”

21 Responses

  1. I’m fast coming to the conclusion that this is all designed to simply ferment societal divisions.

    Gellar has of late lent more and more support to the likes of the EDL, which is counter-intuitive given their [alleged] links with the BNP.

    Gellar must strike a cord in the US however, because it would seem that she is very popular?

  2. Muslim leaders and communities should allow people the right to leave Islam without civil penalty, intimidation, harassment or death threats.

    Christians, Jews and everyone else has got over this. But in most Muslim-majority countries you will be legally sanctioned or worse for leaving Islam.

    Ask our Muslim friends if ‘no compulsion in religion’ means the ability to leave Islam without civil penalty or intimidation. I have rarely received a straight answer.

  3. I feel the ads should be removed claiming that Jesus followed the Islamic way of life. I find that offensive. Bend your will to mine please. I am easily offended and may kill you because Jesus told me to, in his Gospels. It was somewhere around “turning the other cheek” so as to make a roundhouse kick easier.

    • Angaarad,

      You are so right!! Christianity is all about peace and love! I mean, its not like the Bible has a death penalty for apostasy………

      Deuteronomy 13:6-10

      “If your very own brother, or your son or daughter, or the wife you love, or your closest friend secretly entices you, saying, “Let us go and worship other gods” (gods that neither you nor your fathers have known, 7 gods of the peoples around you, whether near or far, from one end of the land to the other), 8 do not yield to him or listen to him. Show him no pity. Do not spare him or shield him. 9You must certainly put him to death. Your hand must be the first in putting him to death, and then the hands of all the people. 10Stone him to death, because he tried to turn you away from the LORD your God, who brought you out of Egypt, out of the land of slavery.”

      Oh, wow, never mind. Errrm, well, thats the Old Testament! And we all know that Jesus abrogated the Old Testament! Right?

      Gospel of Matthew 5:17-20

      “17″Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. 18I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke of a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law until everything is accomplished. 19Anyone who breaks one of the least of these commandments and teaches others to do the same will be called least in the kingdom of heaven, but whoever practices and teaches these commands will be called great in the kingdom of heaven. 20For I tell you that unless your righteousness surpasses that of the Pharisees and the teachers of the law, you will certainly not enter the kingdom of heaven. ”

      Oh dear…..

  4. Hot off the press…

    Miami-Dade Transit to remove ‘offensive’ Islamic bus ads

    http://www.miamiherald.com/2010/04/16/1581903/miami-dade-transit-says-it-will.html

    Pamela Geller’s response…

    WE ARE SUING MIAMI-DADE TRANSIT! Help Us fight!
    “Today I am proud to announce that Robert and I are going to file suit against Miami-Dade Transit …We will sue for breach of contract and violation of the first amendment.”

    I am deeply grateful that…will handle this matter as fully pro bono…But there are costs involved…I am asking…readers…and…supporters to please donate to the legal fund. Please… does not raise funds from the public like…, so any funds I can raise to offset his costs allows him to do more of these.”

    and man! They really put her in defensive mode in one of the posts in particular. Does my heart good. 4 entries today about that alone.

    See her main page if it’s not too painful to your brain or computer.

  5. This is absolutely wonderful news for freedom of religion in America. Islam is such a shoddy, backward belief systeme that it can only maintain the loyaly of its adherents by threatening them with death if they leave the cult.

    To deny the intimidation, threats and even murder of ex-muslim apostates is tantamount to supporting fascism.

    CAIR, seeings it’s a MB front organisation and that it supports and portrays the tenors of salafist thought ( such as Yusuf Qaradawi), could never be or become a Civil Rights organisation in the way we understand Civil Rights.
    http://www.spittoon.org/archives/5367

  6. […] of America organization (currently on a roll following the “Leaving Islam?” bus-ad controversy), this is all a ruse – the purpose of the mosque is to gloat over the site of the World Trade […]

  7. The tenors of salafist thought? There’s a fantastic mental image there.

  8. […] Stop Islamization of America is now advertising on taxis in Chicago, using photos of  girls and women murdered in honour killings to promote its “Leave Islam Safely” website . Similar ads have featured on buses, as I blogged here. […]

  9. Deuteronomy 13:6-9 “If your very own brother, or your son or daughter, or the wife you love, or your closest friend secretly entices you, saying: Let us go and worship other gods (gods that neither you nor your fathers have known, gods of the peoples around you, whether near or far, from one end of the land to the other, or gods of other religions), do not yield to him or listen to him. Show him no pity. Do not spare him or shield him. You must certainly put him to death. Your hand must be the first in putting him to death, and then the hands of all the people.”

    “Do not think that I have come to abolish the Law (the Old Testament) or the Prophets; I have not come to abolish them but to fulfill them. I tell you the truth, until heaven and earth disappear, not the smallest letter, not the least stroke or a pen, will by any means disappear from the Law (the Old Testament) until everything is accomplished. (Matthew 5:17-18)”

  10. […] a “co-founder” of SIOA, despite my previous post’s headline; Geller and Spencer actually inherited SIOA from Kendra Adams a few months ago, and the articles of agreement on which Jay’s […]

  11. […] over the handling of the Rifqa Bary case, and it’s perhaps significant that Geller’s Stop Islamization of America (SIOA) does not get a mention anywhere. One gets the impression that the rally was an attempt to […]

  12. Everybody on this earth must have the freedom to bear his/her own religious views and also to quit one and take another according to his/her wisdom.
    when one is born , from the childhood ,parents feed the infant with their beliefs.most would not bother to question themselves about them even at their elder ages.
    The best way to choose a religion is first to become a free thinker, study all religions on earth at least moderately,and history of them.You will realize, The concept of god /allah has shed blood throughout the history(look in to wars fought christians & muslims) . This bitter truth can be found after studying the history.
    The best choice for one to be in peace and harmony is to spread loving kindness to all living beings in the universe.
    It is time to leave all almighties , imagines,& fictious beings and things. world will be a better place to live.No hatreds , No enemies. ONLY THE PEACE

  13. […] Information about who is behind these various groups is sparse (Stephen Gash “retired” from SOIE in September), although Norway’s group is run by a journalist named Arne Tumyr. Geller took control of SIOA earlier this year, as I noted here. […]

  14. […] to Refuge From Islam, a website listing resources for people considering leaving Islam. Spencer publicly stated, “We wanted to show that some people will stand up against violent intimidation, some people will […]

  15. […] to Refuge From Islam, a website listing resources for people considering leaving Islam. Spencer publicly stated, “We wanted to show that some people will stand up against violent intimidation, some people will […]

  16. […] kilder: Bartholomew’s Notes on Religion, Bartholomew’s Notes on Religion, Bartholomew’s Notes on Religion, deaconjohn’s […]

  17. […] references Geller’s “Stop the Islamization of America” organisation, which she took over from DL Adams and Kendra Adams in April 2010 at the request of Anders Gravers and Stephen Gash of […]

  18. […] to Weasel Zippers following a post by “BigFurHat”, a conservative satirist who created Geller’s logo for SIOA. Geller’s associate Robert Spencer then wrote that: Zip and I had once been […]

  19. […] Meanwhile, Rawlinson has responded to the claim that he is “lying outright” by posting a screenshot of his request, which was sent to the Facebook page of their Stop Islamization of America organisation. […]

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>