USA Today Op-Ed Claims David Barton and John Hagee are “Marginal Figures”

Three completely marginal amigos

2006: At USA Today, Mark I Pinsky explains how John Hagee is a central figure in a new alliance between “Southern Jews and Evangelicals”:

…[I]n November 2005, more than 1,000 evangelicals from central Florida gathered at a local hotel and raised more than $100,000 to buy an ambulance for Magen David Adom, Israel’s Red Cross. Local rabbis delivered both the invocation and the benediction. As event sponsors promised, there was no effort to proselytize any of the estimated 200 Jewish guests. The Rev. John Hagee of San Antonio gave a thunderous keynote address supporting the Jewish state that he could easily have delivered at a rally for Israel’s hard-line Likud Party.

2011: At USA Today, Mark I Pinsky explains how John Hagee is an absolutely marginal figure in Evangelicalism, a bogeyman puffed up by liberal websites but in truth so irrelevant that we don’t even have to spell his name correctly:

These days, it’s hard to turn to liberal websites, public radio or MSNBC without encountering some “investigation” or “exposé” of a splinter, marginal figure, such as David Barton or John Haggee, from the evangelical world — followed by some tenuous if not tortured connect-the-dots link to a presidential or congressional candidate. 

As readers may recall, Hagee’s link to John McCain in 2008 was so “tenuous” that McCain was obliged to issue a  repudiation of Hagee’s endorsement after a sermon came to light in which Hagee referred to Hitler as a “hunter” sent by God to persuade Jews to move to Israel. That sermon was unearthed not by a professional religion writer such as Pinsky, but by an independent amateur researcher named Bruce Wilson.

Hagee as Forrest Gump: marginal figure appears on stage with John McCain

Pinsky complains that:

…beginning in 2006 and every two years since in the run-up to the presidential and off-year congressional elections, books and articles suddenly appear — often written by Jews — about the menace and weirdness of evangelical Christianity.

Though some of the writers hail from Brooklyn or Washington, D.C., the tone is what I’d call “Upper West Side hysteric,” a reference to the fabled New York City neighborhood.

…Chief among these are books such as Michelle Goldberg’s Kingdom Coming: The Rise of Christian Nationalism, Rabbi James Rudin’s The Baptizing of America, and several titles by Sara Diamond.

Bill Berkowitz has written a response:

The essence of the matter is this: A number of conservative writers and political pundits have taken to attacking left-wing investigative reporters, researchers and journalists over their reporting about Dominionism, Christian Reconstructionism and the New Apostolic Reformation – three little-known theological and ideological movements gaining ground on the Christian Right.

The subtext of [Pinsky’s] recent contribution to this newly minted genre appears to be a not-so-subtle message to Jewish writers, researchers and critics of the Religious Right: “Don’t rock the boat.”

Of course one should be careful not to conflate Evangelicalism or neo-Pentecostalism in general with the Christian Right. Evangelicals have a range of political and religious views, and a “top-down” research approach which concentrates on Christian Right ideologues and texts should not claim to have the full picture of Evangelicalism (I’ve previously complained about pseudo-research on Islam which suffers from just this failing). However, Fred Clarkson explains that the writers Pinsky attacks do know the difference between Evangelicals and the Christian Right:

I would ordinarily be glad to join Pinsky in criticizing people who make sweeping, factually unsupported generalizations about evangelicals. Good reporting and scholarship requires using fair terms, making reasonable distinctions, and drawing well-founded conclusions based on facts.  But I cannot join Pinsky in this case, because none of the writers he names engage in the behavior he complains about…

The fact is that the Christian Right is a part of Evangelicalism, whether or not Evangelicals or their supporters find this observation congenial. Evangelicalism is the context in which the Christian Right operates, and it is from Evangelicalism that the Christian Right draws most of its support and influence. And understanding the Christian Right increasingly means understanding the likes of Barton and Hagee, rather than cheesy televangelists from the 1980s.

Some religion journalists appear not to know much about trends such as the New Apostolic Reformation, and have complacently concluded that their ignorance indicates insignificance. There is also some scepticism due to the fact that many of those writing on the subject have an activist motivation – this motivation is often politically progressive, although various kinds of dissenting conservative Evangelicals have also made contributions. However, it should be needless to point out that what motivates someone to write about a subject is a different matter from the quality of the resulting research or analysis, which can be assessed independently.

But in Pinsky’s case, the 2006 quote above suggests another explanation for his dismissive attitude. Bill writes:

[Pinsky] being so off base about David Barton, and John Hagee, I originally figured that he might not really be paying attention to current developments.

But Rachel Tabachnick disabused me of that notion. In a conversation thread on her Facebook page, Tabachnick pointed out that Pinsky “has written repeatedly about Hagee in the Orlando Sentinel, in USA Today and in his own book. … This is not ignorance. This was willfully misleading readers.”

5 Responses

  1. Hi Richard – I should mention that Mark I. Pinsky has an extended treatment on the wisdom of Jews partnering with Hagee and his fellow Christian Zionists, in Pinsky’s book “A Jew Among the Evangelicals: A Guide for the Perplexed” (2006, Westminster John Knox Press), pages 38-42 (which can be viewed through the “look inside [this book]” feature.)

    In his book, Pinsky writes of attending a November 2005 Florida Hagee/Christian Zionism event orchestrated by “Steve Strang”, Charisma magazine publisher. Strang, at the time, was a listed apostle (and into 2008) in C. Peter Wagner’s International Coalition of Apostles–a fact which Pinsky seems unaware of.

    Mark Pinsky’s treatment of the event would tend to give uninformed readers gives an impression of journalistic objectivity, but Pinsky doesn’t seem to have bothered to dig very deeply into his subject matter. Only a few months earlier, prior to the November 2005 Hagee/Strang rally, John Hagee had given his now infamous “God sent Hitler” sermon–that Hagee’s ministry later packaged and sold as a consumer product, in CD and DVD format.

    Pinsky seems generally unaware of pastor Hagee’s truly dark underside–for example, Hagee’s promotion of the claim that European Rothschild bankers control the US economy through the Federal Reserve (the ADL calls this particular conspiracy theory a “Classic Anti-Semitic Myth”.)

  2. […] I previously blogged on Mark Pinsky, who is discussed in the letter, here.  […]

  3. On the contrary, at the time and in my book I wrote about Hagee’s dark side, in particular, his support for right wing social issues and for Christian proselytizing in Israel.

    • Mark, if you were you truly aware that John Hagee was broadcasting a near-variant of the “Protocols” to an international audience and also putting it into best selling books, why didn’t you see fit to mention this?

      One book of Hagee’s, which I own, that claims European-based Rothschilds control the US economy, is billed as having sold over 1 million copies.

      That’s only one of the rather vicious anti-Jewish memes, slurs and stereotypes that John Hagee has promoted to large audiences. Hagee also has claimed that the coming antichrist figure he anticipates will slaughter up to 1/3 of the world’s population will be homosexual and “partially Jewish” (as was Adolf Hitler, claims Hagee.)

      Hagee’s support for right wing social issues has been no secret, but that is very far from the darkest Hagee has to offer. Rachel Tabachnick and I have compiled a sourced collection of quotes from Hagee books, sermons, and videos which you can find at Talk To Action:


  4. I have expanded and refined my position on Jews and evangelicals in the past week in columns on Huffington Post and the Jewish intellectual monthly magazine Moment. Feel free to fire away. Mark Pinsky

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.